Rodeway Inn & Suites Ithaca NY Hotel

  654 Elmira Road, Ithaca, New York 14850, US
+1 (607) 272-5252    support@reviewter.com
Hotel Website

Write Review Book Room

Hotel Description

The Rodeway Inn & Suitesร‚ยฎ hotel is conveniently located just minutes from several educational institutions, like Ithaca College, Cornell University and Tompkins Cortland Community College. This Ithaca, NY hotel provides easy access to many local attractions, including the Sciencenter, featuring exhibits, activities and hands-on programs for the entire family.

43 Reviews from our Reviewter Community

Traveller rating

Service
location
Rooms

Traveller type

Business      (35)
Couples      (1)
Family      (5)
Friends      (1)
Solo      (1)

Language

English

Travellers Reviews

Debbie Johnston

Debbie Johnston

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great place"


I think the Rodeway Inn is a great value hotel. The room was very clean, the bed was extremely comfortable and the family who owns it is super accommodating and hard-working. I don't write reviews often, but I was completely happy with my stay and the price is right.

Listen Review
Reviewed 03, March 2023

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Cedric Gaillard

Cedric Gaillard

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great place"


Great rooms and amenities, pleasant team yet breakfast can be improved in variety Thank you again

Listen Review
Reviewed 07, February 2023

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Jennifer Walter

Jennifer Walter

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great place"


This was my first time staying in Ithaca by myself and I am glad I chose Rodeway. The hotels downtown were way outside my budget but I felt that Rodeway was fairly priced for the area and accommodations offered. The rooms were spacious and clean and I had a great night sleep the first night. I was surprised that the main road got so quiet at night; after 10 pm, there was barely any traffic noise. On the second night there were some people hanging out outside their rooms and we could hear them talking into the evening. Unfortunately I think that's just the downside of some of the rooms having doors that open motel-style, directly to the outdoors. But thankfully we could barely hear anything through the walls. The staff at Rodeway were very friendly and accommodating. You can tell they really care about the guests there. After I left the hotel, I noticed that the vanity plate on the front of the car was missing, so I called the hotel to check f they had seen it in the parking lot. I wasn't sure if it fell off or if someone had stolen it, so I was kinda worried! The staff promised to check for me and call back if the found anything. It turns out the plate fell off somewhere else in town, but I really appreciated the reassurance from the folks at Rodeway that they would help me look for it. I will definitely be back in the future!

Listen Review
Reviewed 10, January 2023

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Bella Michelle

Bella Michelle

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


Even though I live less than an hour away, I have stayed here a few times whether I was exhausted, just needed a place to be alone, or because of storms and have always had a great experience! I have stayed here by myself as well as with friends. There was one time a few years ago, I had to stay due to a blizzard and I was given a discount. I have been given upgrades before without asking and have appreciated it. I always recommend this hotel to people and choose it often when looking for a place to stay! I love that it's family owned as well and I have always been treated so nicely! Thank you!!

Listen Review
Reviewed 14, December 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Khana

Khana

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great place"


๐‘ช๐’๐’†๐’‚๐’ ๐’“๐’๐’๐’Ž, ๐’‡๐’“๐’Š๐’†๐’๐’…๐’๐’š ๐’”๐’•๐’‚๐’‡๐’‡! good location, breakfast better than the expected.

Listen Review
Reviewed 11, November 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Rita

Rita

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


๐’๐’˜๐’๐’†๐’“๐’” ๐’‚๐’“๐’† ๐’—๐’†๐’“๐’š ๐’‡๐’“๐’Š๐’†๐’๐’…๐’๐’š, ๐’„๐’๐’†๐’‚๐’๐’๐’Š๐’๐’†๐’”๐’” convenience to Cornell Univ

Listen Review
Reviewed 11, November 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Clint Miller

Clint Miller

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great place"


Believe the 5 star reviews. This is the nicest place for the price that Iโ€™ve ever stayed in. Front desk staff was pleasant and efficient. Room was clean (actually smelled like it has been freshly cleaned not musty or smokey like most places). Breakfast was tasty with lots of options. Itโ€™s walking distance to Ithaca Beer Co and 5 minutes from downtown.

Listen Review
Reviewed 16, October 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Blanca Osorio

Blanca Osorio

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


I love it is a nice hotel super clean everything is beautiful ๐Ÿ˜ I really recommend this nice hotel !!

Listen Review
Reviewed 14, September 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Rebecca

Rebecca

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great staff"


If I could give more than 5 stars I would! Room was clean and staff were amazing. I was coming from Colorado so my Great Dane could have heart surgery at Cornell University. This hotel was the only one who asked if my dog was well behaved and allowed him to stay here. I would think with Cornell having a prestigious vet program and people traveling so their dog could have procedures done here that there would be more hotels friendly to all dogs. Definitely stay here if traveling to Ithaca

Listen Review
Reviewed 11, August 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Louie_V

Louie_V

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Staff"


Awesome location and breakfast. Rooms were clean with great AC.

Listen Review
Reviewed 21, July 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Jamie Mansfield

Jamie Mansfield

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great staff"


Very good place to stay

Listen Review
Reviewed 14, June 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Lisa

Lisa

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


Exceptional Good hospitality

Listen Review
Reviewed 19, May 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Johntu Reed jr

Johntu Reed jr

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


This place was a hidden Gem!! ThanksKayan5โ˜†+ So quiet, we only heard a few crickets๐Ÿ˜. Very Clean and Comfortable, Food was great, warm welcoming, comfy pillows.Thank you Rodeway Inn for a great Stay while we explored Ithaca, waterfalls, and CUniversity ๐Ÿ’™

Listen Review
Reviewed 15, April 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Dylan Avery

Dylan Avery

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


It's quiet, it's modern, and it's owned by a lovely gentleman.

Listen Review
Reviewed 21, March 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Zachary

Zachary

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


๐‘น๐’†๐’”๐’•๐’‡๐’–๐’ ๐’‚๐’๐’… ๐‘ฌ๐’๐’‹๐’๐’š๐’‚๐’ƒ๐’๐’† ๐’˜๐’†๐’†๐’Œ๐’†๐’๐’…. ๐’˜๐’๐’–๐’๐’… ๐’…๐’ ๐’‚๐’ˆ๐’‚๐’Š๐’! it was clean and nicely remodeled

Listen Review
Reviewed 17, February 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Hector Sanchez

Hector Sanchez

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Place"


Quit and clean place to rest after a day in beautiful Ithaca.

Listen Review
Reviewed 04, February 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Jill

Jill

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


๐’—๐’†๐’“๐’š ๐’๐’Š๐’„๐’†, ๐’•๐’‰๐’‚๐’๐’Œ ๐’š๐’๐’– nice clean room, well heated in winter we have stayed here a few times, always satisfied good value

Listen Review
Reviewed 10, January 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Hector Sanchez

Hector Sanchez

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Place"


Quit and clean place to rest after a day in beautiful Ithaca.

Listen Review
Reviewed 06, January 2022

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Hector Sanchez

Hector Sanchez

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


Quit and clean place to rest after a day in beautiful Ithaca.

Listen Review
Reviewed 15, December 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
John Sheffield

John Sheffield

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Place"


Nice rooms: clean and quiet, good size. reasonable rates. MOST IMPORTANTLY: Great customer service, polite, warm courteous, accommodating to needs. They are NOT using Covid as an excuse to cut corners and limit service as so many in the industry are.

Listen Review
Reviewed 31, October 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Victoria Zenina

Victoria Zenina

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


Nice small clean hotel. There are rooms with one double bed, there are rooms with two double beds. The room has a refrigerator, microwave, coffee maker, hairdryer, iron, ironing board. Breakfast included.

Listen Review
Reviewed 11, October 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Dale Waterhouse

Dale Waterhouse

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Place"


The staff is very friendly, the rooms are very clean. My wife and I have no complaints. We've stayed here 3 times and will again next time we come to Ithaca.

Listen Review
Reviewed 01, October 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Dale Waterhouse

Dale Waterhouse

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Place"


The staff is very friendly, the rooms are very clean. My wife and I have no complaints. We've stayed here 3 times and will again next time we come to Ithaca.

Listen Review
Reviewed 14, September 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Terry Landrigan

Terry Landrigan

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Helpful Staff"


Clean and pleasant. No frills except hot breakfast with waffle maker.

Listen Review
Reviewed 12, August 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Gwen Snelbaker

Gwen Snelbaker

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


Very nice, well cared for, clean. My only complaint was the noise from the hallway, but I can chalk that up to rude people

Listen Review
Reviewed 04, July 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Joseph Pavelites

Joseph Pavelites

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Service"


When visiting the University, I always stop here. Clean, affordable rooms that are just a few minutes away from everything in Ithaca.

Listen Review
Reviewed 04, June 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
neal donnelly

neal donnelly

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Place"


Very nice place . Very clean and nice staff. Would go back to there again . Dog friendly .

Listen Review
Reviewed 10, May 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
S M

S M

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Place"


Super

Listen Review
Reviewed 20, April 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Kathleen R

Kathleen R

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great experience"


This hotel was so clean and so comfortable! The bed is wonderful, the shower fantastic. The staff were so courteous and terrific in helping me with everything. The breakfast the next day was delicious and hot. An incredible place to stay for a very low price in a gorgeous area! Close to beautiful hikes also close to food and shops! I'd easily stay again!

Listen Review
Reviewed 08, March 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Prash

Prash

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"nice expereince"


Really liked the hotel, peaceful location with awesome views of the hill. Neat and clean recently renovated. Shrikant was really helpful. More importantly one of only hotels which allows pet.

Listen Review
Reviewed 19, February 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
John Kizner

John Kizner

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"great experience"


Stayed February 20, 2020. Had a great stay was taken care of called in advance to let them know I was coming, they went and turned on the heater to get the room warm. This will be my go to place when in Ithaca, Ny. Keep up the great service. Thank you.

Listen Review
Reviewed 06, January 2021

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Aaron Blake

Aaron Blake

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"price"


Decent priced and very well kept.

Listen Review
Reviewed 27, December 2020

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Mary Ann Mazz

Mary Ann Mazz

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Highly recommend!"


Highly recommend! Very clean, modern decor, comfortable and accommodating. Karan at the desk was very helpful. Gave great suggestions for restaurants. Fair prices, good location!

Listen Review
Reviewed 17, October 2020

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Lisa A Wehrle

Lisa A Wehrle

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Wonderful place to stay"


The room and hotel was immaculate. The owners were delightful. A family run business and they couldn't be more helpful. We will be going back there in a couple of weeks. The location is perfect to downtown Ithaca and the Trueman State Park, and Buttermilk Park. Highly recommend this Rodeway Inn.

Listen Review
Reviewed 16, September 2020

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Lisa Conger

Lisa Conger

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Fabulous Stay!!"


My high school bff and I finally had a couple of days for a girls mini vacation, so, we planned a trip to Ithaca to hike the falls in the area. Since we were only staying for one night, spending a lot of money wasn't necessary so we got this room for a very reasonable price and it was so much more then we expected being on the outside of town limits. Our room was incredibility clean!! The beds were nice and firm and comfortable! The shower felt amazing! The WiFi was slow, but it's free so you get what you pay for there. Also, full breakfast, eggs, ham, hash browns and really great coffee!! This was an awesome choice, we couldn't have asked for a better room!! This will be my go to hotel, the next time I plan to visit this area.

Listen Review
Reviewed 06, July 2019

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Florence N.

Florence N.

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great place to stay.."


I was very happy with my stay. The room was beautiful..clean and completely renovated. The bed was very comfortable..good nights sleep. Nice having refrig ..microwave and coffee pot in room. I was attending funeral in Ithaca so location very convient. I want to thank owner/proprietor Karan for his assistance and facilitating my request. He was very nice and helpful. I would recommend this place to anyone needing a motel.

Listen Review
Reviewed 03, July 2019

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Neal and Deb Krieger

Neal and Deb Krieger

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Fantastic Place to Stay"


The owners, Patrick and family, were very courteous and friendly. Our room was clean, comfortable and affordable. An excellent place to stay while traveling around to the waterfalls. Their free breakfast was great and the area was clean and plenty of space to eat and plenty of food. Thank you all ๐Ÿ˜€

Listen Review
Reviewed 21, October 2018

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Gerry

Gerry

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great Hotel for a Great Price!"


I had to visit Ithaca to attend a funeral and was looking online for a hotel. The first hotel that came up in the search was the Rodeway Inn. At first I went past it to the other chain hotels in the area. I was surprised at how expensive the hotels were. I then looked again at Rodeway Inn and thought that for the price of the room it really can't be that good. Then I started reading all the great reviews and decided that i would give it a try. I am very happy to say that the hotel was just great. The room was super clean, the shower was great and the bed very comfortable. The room was just as good as any other of the big named hotels in the area. I later found out that i paid $100 less for my room! And as a plus the breakfast was also just as good as any of the other "fancier" places. If you're going to Ithaca stay at the Rodeway Inn. You won't be disappointed!!

Listen Review
Reviewed 02, August 2018

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Chris

Chris

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Excellent staff"


The rooms are clean and the staff and owners are extremely friendly. When we walked into our room and a few things were broken the owners immediately took action to replace or fix the problems. We were in town for a swim meet and they were kind enough to open breakfast an hour earlier so our swimmers could get something to eat before they headed to the pool at Ithaca College. It may not look like much driving by, but the Rodeway Inn is definitely a place I would recommend and stay at again.

Listen Review
Reviewed 26, March 2018

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
laroy nelson

laroy nelson

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"03/23/2018"


this is my 3rd stay here at this hotel and i have to say the rooms are always clean, the staff is very helpful and friendly. i don't have a one bad thing to say about them

Listen Review
Reviewed 23, March 2018

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Tim

Tim

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Hunting trip"


Reserved a room at rodeway in Ithaca for hunting trip room was excellent, service was great, they put lots of money into the place best motel i been to

Listen Review
Reviewed 21, January 2018

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Laura Walsh

Laura Walsh

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great price great people "


We had a family trip to Ithaca. At first we were nervous because the place is under repairs. But once we got to our room. Wow what a nice place. Every one was very nice. The traffic getting in and out was a bit ruff but we just had to have a little bit of patients.

Listen Review
Reviewed 01, October 2017

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Shawn

Shawn

1 Review

Level 1 Contributor

"Great"


Great stay

Listen Review
Reviewed 18, August 2017

Rating

Service
Location
Rooms
Hotel Reviews :- 43
    New York Hotels 46
Hotel Video
Google Map
Popular Tags
Hotels in New York Motels in New York New York reviews Ithaca reviews Hotels in Ithaca Motels in Ithaca Read Reviews Ithaca Read Reviews New York Hotel Guest Review Book hotel online
Hotel List